NCERT Solutions for Class 9th Science Chapter 9 .4.2 Bonding by electron transfer — In-text Questions

Book page 1729 Updated on2026-09-08

Q1.
If the valence shell of an atom has less than four electrons, it would generally donate its valence electrons to achieve a stable electronic configuration. Identify four such elements among the first 18 elements by using their electronic configurations given in Table 8.4 of the Chapter 8, Journey Inside the Atom.
Answer

Lithium, beryllium, sodium, magnesium and aluminium — any four of these.

ElementZElectronic configurationValence electronsIon formed on donating them
Lithium (Li)32, 11Li⁺
Beryllium (Be)42, 22Be²⁺
Sodium (Na)112, 8, 11Na⁺
Magnesium (Mg)122, 8, 22Mg²⁺
Aluminium (Al)132, 8, 33Al³⁺
Why it happens: giving away 1, 2 or 3 electrons is a short journey; gaining 5, 6 or 7 to complete an octet is a long one. When sodium (2, 8, 1) loses its single M-shell electron, the shell underneath is already a full 2, 8 — the same stable arrangement as neon. So one small loss buys a complete octet. That is why elements with fewer than four valence electrons are metals and form cations.
Tip: boron (2, 3) also has fewer than four valence electrons, but with three electrons to give and a small, tightly holding atom it prefers to share. The “less than four → donate” rule is a good guide, not a law.
Q2.
Will it still be neutral after losing one electron? If not, what charge would it carry and why?
Answer

No — a sodium atom that has lost one electron is no longer neutral. It carries a charge of +1 and is called the sodium cation, Na⁺.

Sodium atom, Z = 11 → 11 protons (+11) and 11 electrons (−11)
Net charge = (+11) + (−11) = 0 — neutral

After losing one electron: 11 protons (+11) and 10 electrons (−10)
Net charge = (+11) + (−10) = +1

The number of protons never changes in a chemical reaction — protons sit in the nucleus and chemistry only ever moves the outer electrons. So removing one electron leaves one proton whose positive charge is no longer balanced.

Why it happens: an atom is neutral only because protons and electrons happen to be equal in number and equal and opposite in charge. Break that equality and a charge appears. Lose electrons and you get a cation (Na⁺, Mg²⁺, Al³⁺); gain them and you get an anion (Cl⁻, O²⁻, S²⁻).
Check it yourself: Na⁺ now has the configuration 2, 8 — the same as neon. It is chemically nothing like a sodium atom: sodium metal reacts violently with water, while Na⁺ in solution is what you eat every day in common salt.
Was this helpful? Report an error