a. Initiatives taken by the ECI to enable the voters to cast their vote
Read the passage line by line and each initiative shows up in it:
- Online voter registration — Ishani "had registered to vote through the ECI's online portal", so a first-time voter did not have to travel to an office to get on the roll.
- Security at the polling station — the station was "well guarded by the police personnel", so voters could come without fear. This answers the "intimidation" pothole of Fig. 7.13.
- Accessibility for PwDs — "A wheelchair was made available to them, and volunteers guided them to the polling booth", for her disabled elder brother.
- Alternative identity documents accepted — she had forgotten her voter ID card and Aadhaar card, but "her identity was verified with an alternative document", so a missing card did not cost her the vote.
- VVPAT — "After casting her vote, she was also able to see the VVPAT slip", which lets a voter verify that the vote was recorded for the intended candidate.
- Home voting for the very elderly — her 89-year-old grandmother cast her vote from home, the facility the chapter describes for senior citizens above 85 years of age.
b. Which other document might she be carrying that is valid for voting?
The ECI publishes a list of alternative photo identity documents that a polling officer may accept when the EPIC is not produced. Any one of these would have served, provided it carries her photograph — for example a passport, a driving licence, a PAN card, a bank or post office passbook with photograph, a service identity card with photograph issued by a Central or State Government, PSU or public limited company, a health insurance smart card, an MGNREGA job card, a pension document with photograph, or a Unique Disability ID (UDID) card. Since Ishani is a school or college student, the most likely one in her bag would be a photo identity card issued by her school or college or her passport.
Note: the chapter says only that "an alternative document" was used and does not print the list. Look up the ECI's current notification of alternative photo identity documents before writing a full list in an examination, and cite it.
c. Examples of violations of the Model Code of Conduct
The passage is set the day before polling, and that timing is what makes the campaigning in it a problem:
- Campaigning during the silence period — pamphlet distribution and slogan-raising by large groups of campaigners in the market on the day before the poll. Public campaigning must stop 48 hours before the close of polling, so that voters have a quiet period in which to make up their minds.
- Defacement of property — "wall writing and campaign posters pasted everywhere". Writing on and pasting posters on walls without the owner's permission, and on public property, is a Model Code violation.
- Large, unregulated gatherings — processions and loud slogan-raising in a crowded market need prior permission; the chapter notes the ECI's Suvidha app exists precisely so that candidates can apply for permission for meetings, rallies, vehicles and loudspeakers.
Two further violations that the RPA 1951 lists, and that a student should watch for even though the passage does not show them, are any gift, offer or promise made to influence a vote, and appeals on the basis of religion, caste, race, community or language. The chapter also names the remedy: any voter can report a Model Code violation through the cVIGIL app within minutes, and flying squads reach the spot using auto-location.
d. A suitable title for the passage
"Ishani's First Vote" — it names the person, the event and the sense of a first time, which is what holds the passage together.
Other good titles, each defensible: "No Voter to Be Left Behind" (the chapter's own phrase, which fits the wheelchair, the alternative document and the grandmother's home vote), "A Day at the Polling Station", or "Every Vote Finds a Way". When you give a title, add one line saying why it fits — that is what earns the mark.
e. How police and army personnel cast their votes
- Armed forces personnel are registered as service voters in their home constituency and vote by postal ballot. Under ETPBS the ballot is transmitted to them electronically wherever they are posted; they print it, mark it and return it by post in time for the count. Members of a State armed police force serving outside their State, and government employees posted outside India, are service voters on the same footing.
- Police and other officials on election duty within their own State are usually not able to be at their own polling station on polling day. They vote either by postal ballot, or on an Election Duty Certificate, which allows a person on duty to vote at the polling station where they are deployed instead of their own.
Why Ishani's question is a good one: she notices that the very people guarding the poll are the people most likely to miss it. An election system that let its own staff fall out of the electorate would fail its own test — which is exactly why the postal ballot, the Election Duty Certificate and ETPBS exist. Verify the current procedure on the ECI website before writing the details in an exam.