NCERT Solutions for Class 9th Social Science Chapter 7 Multi-party system and defection — In-text Questions

Book page 175 Updated on2026-09-08

Q1.
If there are so many political parties, can someone simply leave one party and join another whenever they wish?
Answer

Yes — a person may leave one party and join another. But once someone has been elected on a particular party's ticket, leaving that party is called defection, and the law then attaches consequences to it.

The chapter defines defection as abandoning or switching from the party under whose banner the candidate was elected. It includes joining another party, and also "choosing to act independently of the party's decisions, particularly in matters such as voting in the legislature."

The chapter deliberately gives you both readings of the same act:

Read through party discipline and stabilityRead through conscience and public expectations
The voter chose the candidate partly because of the party's programme. Switching afterwards changes what the voter bought without asking them, so it is seen as political opportunism, and repeated switching can bring down governments and make policy unstable.A member may come to believe the party is wrong, or that opinion in the constituency has moved. On this reading, obeying one's conscience or responding to changing public expectations is a legitimate part of representing people rather than a betrayal.

What the law does. The Anti-Defection Law was passed in 1985 through the 52nd Constitutional Amendment Act, to prevent defection and give the elected government stability. Under it, a member of Parliament or of a State Assembly who voluntarily gives up party membership, or votes against the party's instructions (whip), can be disqualified from the House. The Speaker or Chairman of the House decides such cases.

Why this is a genuine dilemma, not a settled question: the law buys stability by reducing a legislator's freedom to vote against their own party. Both things are valuable in a democracy, and strengthening one weakens the other. The chapter presents both sides without deciding between them, and so should you when you write about it.
Was this helpful? Report an error