Q9.
Why does a fireperson sometimes struggle when holding the pipe issuing water?
Answer
Because the water pushes the hose backwards with a force equal to the force the hose uses to push the water forwards — and that backward force can be very large.
Hose pushes water forwards at high speed, with force F
Newton's third law → water pushes hose backwards with force F
The fireperson must supply a forward force of F just to keep the hose still
Fast-moving water = large change of momentum every second = large F
Newton's third law → water pushes hose backwards with force F
The fireperson must supply a forward force of F just to keep the hose still
Fast-moving water = large change of momentum every second = large F
Why the force is so big: a fire hose throws out several kilograms of water every second at a very high speed. Producing that large change of velocity in the water in so short a time needs a large force (F = ma), and the reaction on the hose is equally large. If the fireperson does not brace hard against it, the net force on hose-plus-person is backwards and they are pushed back — which is why firefighters often hold the nozzle in pairs and lean into it.
Tip: a rocket, a canoe paddle and a fire hose are the same physics: throw mass one way, get pushed the other way.